Judge holds off on Visa, Mastercard swipe-fee settlement
Based on Reuters' Nov. 16, 2026 report of the hearing, via Investing.com; a same-day release from the Merchants Payments Coalition, which opposes the deal; and the court-authorized settlement website. This updates our earlier story on the proposed settlement. As of Nov. 18, 2026.
What happened
U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan in Brooklyn held a hearing on Nov. 16 on whether to give final approval to Visa and Mastercard's proposed swipe-fee settlement with merchants, and he did not rule, Reuters reported.
The court-authorized settlement website, checked Nov. 18, 2026, still says the court "has not yet given its final approval to this Settlement."
Reuters said Cogan "did not decide at a hearing whether to grant final approval, though he said rejecting the settlement could lead to a 'protracted process' if the 21-year-old case went to trial." The Merchants Payments Coalition, which opposes the deal, said the judge also told the court, "If I reject this, it's going to trial." Reuters did not carry that sentence; we are using the coalition's account for that quote.
Why it matters to you
Nothing on your card-fee line changes until the judge rules. If he later approves the deal, the proposed cut would be small, delayed, and not a promise about your own rate. We covered the terms, the class, and the timeline in our earlier story. This piece covers what happened at the hearing.
What the proposed deal would still do
These terms are unchanged from the agreement we described earlier. None of them apply unless the judge gives final approval.
Reuters reported that the settlement would lower swipe fees by 0.1 percentage point for five years and cap fees on standard consumer cards at 1.25% for eight years. As we wrote earlier, the 0.10-point cut is a network-wide average, not a promise for every card or every merchant.
The deal would also end the longstanding "Honor All Cards" rule by letting merchants choose among cards in three groups: commercial cards, premium consumer cards including rewards cards, and standard consumer cards, Reuters reported.
For scale: if a full 0.10-point cut reached your rate, you'd save $100 a year for every $100,000 in Visa and Mastercard credit card sales (our math: 0.001 × $100,000 = $100). That's the best case, and only if your processor passes the full cut through to you. In our earlier reading of the agreement, we found no requirement that processors do that. The Merchants Payments Coalition, which opposes the deal, said the average fee merchants paid in 2025 was 2.36%. That's an industry average the coalition published, not your rate. Your processing statement shows what you pay.
Reuters, citing two experts hired by the plaintiffs, said the changes could save merchants $38 billion by 2031. That figure is the experts' estimate of savings over time, not a cash payment to you. As we reported earlier, the settlement website says the deal pays merchants no money.
Who spoke at the hearing
Visa and Mastercard urged the judge to approve the deal. Visa's lawyer, Michael Shuster, said the settlement offers "potent" relief for merchants and that the network is not "jumping with joy" at the changes. "It's going to change life for the networks," he said, according to Reuters.
The Electronic Payments Coalition, whose members include Visa, Mastercard and large issuers, supported the settlement, Reuters reported. After the hearing, EPC Executive Chairman Richard Hunt said the deal would provide businesses "substantial financial benefits, greater flexibility and more options."
The court received slightly more than 1,000 objections, including from Walmart and the National Retail Federation, Reuters reported. That is in line with the September objections we covered earlier.
Mithun Mansinghani, a lawyer representing the National Association of Convenience Stores and Circle K, which both objected, told the judge, "Competition should be the North Star ... and this settlement is way off course," according to Reuters. The same quote appears in the coalition's release.
What this means for owners
- Nothing changes yet. The hearing happened; the ruling did not. Your current Visa and Mastercard rates still apply.
- If the judge approves, the cut would be small, and not immediate. The earlier story's timeline still holds: card-acceptance and card-fee rules would start within 90 days after final judgment; rate cuts and caps would start no earlier than four months later, timed to the networks' April and October updates. If a full 0.10-point cut reached your rate, that's $100 a year per $100,000 in those credit card sales (our math: 0.001 × $100,000 = $100), and only if your processor passes it through.
- The questions for your processor have not changed. How is your rate built? If interchange drops, will your rate drop, and when would you see it? Can the system tell premium and commercial cards apart? What are the rules in your state for adding a card fee or offering a cash discount?
Details may change; we'll update this piece when the judge rules.
Sources
- Reuters, "Visa, Mastercard urge approval of $38 billion swipe fee settlement," Jonathan Stempel, Nov. 16, 2026, via Investing.com (checked Nov. 18, 2026)
- Merchants Payments Coalition, "More than 1,000 Merchants Urge Judge to Reject 'Flawed' Visa/Mastercard Swipe Fee Settlement," Nov. 16, 2026 (checked Nov. 18, 2026; the coalition opposes the deal)
- Interchange B2 Settlement (court-authorized settlement website), home page (checked Nov. 18, 2026; still says the court has not given final approval)
- Electronic Payments Coalition, "EPC Statement on Payment Network, Business Settlement Agreement Hearing," Nov. 16, 2026 (checked Nov. 16, 2026)
- Ser.vi News, "Visa, Mastercard seek final OK of swipe-fee deal: What would change," Nov. 5, 2026 (prior story; terms and timeline unchanged)
- Ser.vi pricing page (checked Nov. 16, 2026; used only for the "From Ser.vi" box)
Ser.vi News is published by Ser.vi, a restaurant POS and online ordering company. Articles follow editorial guidelines set by Ser.vi leadership. Companies we cover don't review articles before publication. Corrections: corrections policy.